Title: A Dance with Dragons: A Song of Ice and Fire: Book Five
Author: George R.R. Martin
Publisher: Harper Collins, Harper Collins India
Genre: Fantasy/Horror
ISBN: 9780007455997
Pages: 1040
Source: Publisher
Rating: 4/5
I loved reading A Dance with Dragons, but I certainly did not always enjoy it. In fact, certain parts of the book are so dark they defy the imagination. Defenders of the darkness of the A Song of Ice and Fire series have often compared the books’ grittiness to the evil of our own reality. But the world that sprang forth from the mind George R. R. Martin is perhaps even darker than our own miserable planet.
Fans of George R.R. Martin’s entire oeuvre will recognize that Martin’s hallmark is a fascination with broken, corrupt, and decaying worlds. Throughout his fiction are found worlds that have once tasted grandeur, but have rotted away through the efforts of both time and humanity. The world of A Song of Ice and Fire is no different. Its lands are filled with ruined cities, extinct civilizations, and scattered peoples who squabble over memories.
Perhaps it is fair that some question why these books should even be called fantasy when they might just as well be labeled as horror? Some of the passages from A Dance with Dragons are far more horrific than anything Hollywood has produced, perhaps ever. But I totally disagree with the notion that fantasy cannot be horrific as well. Too long have we suffered fantasy literature that dwells endlessly in shining castles. Soon enough, the grand castles, gleaming swords, and sage wizards become bland without some truly horrific stuff to spice it all up. Martin provides us with the spices we all crave. They may burn our mouths when we eat them, but once we have tasted them, we crave them. Not everyone can handle spicy food, and not everyone can handle fantasy books filled to the brim with rape, torture, mutilation, cannibalism, and all the other unpleasantries of life.
Even if it can be a little dark, A Dance with Dragons is definitely the most magical and fantastical of the books so far. Bran’s portion of the story alone was wonderful to read and would probably have made for a great children’s fantasy if not for all the the violence. With the return of dragons to the world, magic and sorcery have been let loose, but never do they overwhelm the human elements of the story. Even the sorceress Melisandre misinterprets her visions and resort to cheap tricks to fool her audience.
Another valid criticism of A Dance with Dragons might be that it is not as tightly wound as the first three books were. But it is a criticism that is only valid if one does not consider the narrative structure of the series as a whole. The series began with almost every character of note gathered at Winterfell. Through the many infamous twists and turn of the books, the story has become shattered like a crystal vase smashed into the ground. One cannot give readers so much thrilling death and destruction as Martin did in the first three books without breaking a lot of vases. But what death caused, death can also cure. Many smaller characters died off in A Dance with Dragons, and the pace will probably accelerate through The Winds of Winter.
It is valuable to remember that Martin has always loved telling short stories set in his broken worlds. And he could not resist inserting some small stories for secondary characters into A Feast for Crows and A Dance with Dragons. The skeptic will use these as evidence that Martin has “lost control of his narrative.” I prefer to describe this tendency as “just plain awesome.” The Chicago Sun-Times once said that A Game of Thrones is “an absorbing combination of the mythic, the sweepingly historical, and the intensely personal.” Where A Feast for Crows was abound with the personal, it lacked the epic portion of the formula. A Dance with Dragons made the personal stories epic in and of themselves.
The book isn’t perfect. Martin uses some phrases and words too freely and repetitively. I don’t think we’ve seen the words niello, neeps, or serjeant before in the series, but they show up again and again throughout the book in multiple diverse contexts. The inner thoughts of many characters consists of the same phrases repeated many times over. It’s effective but definitely not subtle.
To be sure, those who scoff at the old chestnut that “The journey is more important than the destination” will surely dislike this book. A Song of Ice and Fire is in many ways like the river journey of Tyrion Lannister or that of Abner Marsh in Martin’s own Fevre Dream or that of Charles Marlow in Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness. That is to say, it is a journey into the darkness of the human soul. A Dance with Dragons is but a leg of that journey, offering scant resolution, but heaps of oppressive doom. The coming winter described so vividly in the novel is but a reflection of the descent of the humans of the novel into a self-imposed hell of hatred, fear, hunger, and death.
Martin’s storytelling skills are intact, at no point did I want to fling this across the room. It kept me reading for a thousand pages. That’s no mean feat. Some sequences are close to fantastic, all the stuff with Reek, Arya’s chapters, the brief glimpses of Jaime and Cersei. Tyrion remains entertaining and once Daenerys becomes a mover and shaker (plus one new character who the jury is still out on) things could happen rapidly. The potential is there. I care about what’s there and what’s missing. I want to know what happens with Bran, with Brielle, with Catelyn Tully and the Vale. I love the flashbacks we get and how Aerys and Rheagar and all the people we never saw feel like real characters even though we’ve only heard about them through the voices of others, how it feels like myth real people witnessed.
You can only hear the “modern Tolkien” comparisons for so long before you start to realize that people are expecting a masterpiece for the new century, when all you wanted to do was tell this nifty fantasy story. But we read and we’re here and for the most part, we’re sticking around until the end. So, just relax and tell the story and let it unfold. It doesn’t need to be perfect and huge and epic and all those things that high fantasy is supposed to be, just good.
Affiliate Link:
Buy A Dance With Dragons from Flipkart.com