Book Review: The Crimson Petal and the White by Michel Faber
Title: The Crimson Petal and the White
Author: Michel Faber
Publisher: Canongate Books Ltd
ISBN: 978-0857860019
Genre: Literary Fiction
PP: 824 pages
Price: £9.99
Source: Publisher
Rating: 5/5
Add me to the list of people who appreciate Faber’s vividly-detailed writing! The setting of this story is so well-described that, for a few nights, I actually dreamt that I was in London’s streets in 1875. Just that alone gets my 5 stars. This book also leaves a lasting impression of the three main characters, William, Sugar, and Agnes.
Sure, William Rackham is a pathetic man who weakly follows the tide, but I think that’s the point. At the beginning of the novel, he’s so overwhelmed by the pressure to become a great man that his life has become stagnant. Sugar’s fire is what pushes his life into fluidity. He discovers (too late) that he also needs his family to make him a great man. This dichotomy is what the title is all about, the crimson petal, of course, being Sugar and the white petal being Agnes. Both petals make a perfume that is just too dangerous of a mix to solve everything. I found it very interesting that Sugar hates roses and thinks that they stink. Could it be because she views HERSELF as a filthy person?
Sugar is especially captivating to follow because she FIGHTS for a better life rather than simply accepting the revolting career that she was cursed with at an early age. If she has to be a prostitute, she’ll be the most sought-after prostitute in the city damn it! She turns to her vengeful novel as an outlet because she knows that taking it out on her customers in real life will get her nowhere. It’s so admirable to see her go above and beyond her duties as a whore to make each disgusting man leave her room feeling special. This is a character with real hope.
And Agnes’ pristine spirit gives a nice balance to the story. *sigh* If only she had the capability to give William everything he needs. But then there wouldn’t be a story, now would there? Her limitations are what set the plot in motion. This woman is so naïve and optimistic that she thinks her competitor is an angel. A strange woman standing at her gate can’t possibly have an ulterior motive! Agnes is so raw that she’s not ready to be a mother to her own child.
But I must say that the book could have done without the characters of Henry Rackham and Emmeline Fox. The ONLY good thing Henry has to offer is his tragic, ironic death. Although I don’t think he committed suicide, I do think his death is the direct cause of his depressed carelessness over something he didn’t even need to worry about in the first place. This makes his death a delicious one. But, we don’t need to waste so much time getting to know Emmeline Fox. (I skipped the parts that were written from her point-of view.) Sure, there is the nice parallel that both she and her father, Doctor Curlew, are “healers” in this horrible world, but we really don’t need so many pages about her. Instead, I would have liked to see more of a presence from the Rescue Society as a whole. (In case you don’t know, their mission is to “save” prostitutes by introducing them into a workforce that is worse than where they were in the first place.) This would have given an interesting aspect to the story.
As far as the highly-criticized ending, my complaint isn’t the open-ended questions that leave the reader hanging. In fact, I revel in this. There’s a feeling of hope that Sugar and Sophie can start afresh and live nice, uncomplicated lives filled with the love that the rest of the world denied them. Adding to this “clean slate” feeling is the awesome part where Sugar’s and Agnes’ life testaments are spilled onto the street. Just as intriguing is the danger that either Sugar or Sophie just might submit to following in her mother’s footsteps to continue the ugly cycle.
Also, I can hardly call this an “abrupt” ending when it’s a small, three-act story in itself (Sugar receives the dismissal letter, she makes several attempts to appeal to William, she has to sacrifice her dignity to Cheesman to get through the gates….) No, my complaint is that nothing really fueled the ending to make it happen in the first place. If William had such admiration for Sugar that it carried us through a story 800+ pages long, how could he so easily dismiss her? Sure, he’s finding Lady Bridgelow attractive lately. Ok, so Sugar’s been tired lately and is losing her luster (this is another nice irony, by the way: she’s losing her “power” over him because of HIS baby). …And he does have that newfound sense of responsibility for getting a more-qualified governess for Sophie…..But to throw Sugar on the street? It just doesn’t fit! To fix this, my suggestion would be to develop more of an intimacy between William and Lady Bridgelow. Perhaps, if they had actually shared a few genuine moments, the ending might have been plausible.
At any rate, I would highly recommend this book to anyone who loves being transported to another world and time. Michael Faber is an absolute genius at accomplishing this. If that is what you love in a story, then you won’t regret picking up this “tome”.
Affiliate Links:









.png)